★ Independent, reader-supported & ad-free · Watching the watchers in all 50 states ★ Support Us
Watch · Our Take

Is your car on a police watch list by mistake? #shorts

Buzzworthy ChitChat · 2 months ago

The short version: A Flock camera reportedly misidentified Amber Newell's car as tied to a Milwaukee homicide, triggering a Brookfield police stop — a stark reminder that ALPR 'hits' are guesses, not proof.

Our Take

Buzzworthy ChitChat's short clip lands on a problem we've been flagging for a while: these systems are sold as neutral, objective tools, but they're really probabilistic guesses dressed up as hard evidence. A misread plate, a similar make and model, or a database error can turn an innocent driver into a 'suspect' the moment an officer's dashboard lights up red. Amber Newell's story is the kind of case that should give every city council pause before signing a Flock contract.

What's chilling isn't just the mistake — it's how fast it escalates. A camera flags a car, officers treat that flag as probable cause, and suddenly someone's pulled over, detained, or worse, based on an algorithm's hunch. There's no public audit trail showing how often these false positives happen, because most agencies don't publish that data. The burden of proof gets quietly shifted from 'police must establish reasonable suspicion' to 'the software said so.'

This is exactly why we track where these cameras are going up and who's paying for them. Check our camera map to see what's watching your own street, and if your town is considering a Flock deal, visit our take-action page for tools to push back before the next misfire has your name — or your license plate — attached to it.

This is DeFlock The USA’s original commentary. The video above is the work of Buzzworthy ChitChat, published on YouTube — full credit to the creator.