★ Independent, reader-supported & ad-free · Watching the watchers in all 50 states ★ Support Us
Watch · Our Take

It has to photograph you to check if it should

Verified Privacy VPN (vp.net) · 2 months ago

The short version: A VPN company's video nails the logical sleight-of-hand in Flock's 'no picture without a match' pitch: the camera has to capture everyone first.

Our Take

Credit to Verified Privacy VPN for stating plainly what city councils keep getting fooled on: the claim that ALPR cameras only take a photo when there's a hot-list hit is backwards. The system has to photograph every single plate, run it against the list, and only then decide whether to flag it. That means total capture is the starting point, not some rare exception. The privacy comes from what happens after the shutter clicks, not before.

This matters because the entire sales pitch to local governments leans on the opposite impression — that these are targeted tools, triggered only by wanted vehicles, like a digital BOLO. In reality every driver, innocent or not, gets logged, timestamped, and geotagged, and that data sits in a database whether or not it ever matched anything. Retention policies and 'audit trails' are a privacy backstop bolted on after the fact, not a limit on what gets collected in the first place. Once the infrastructure exists to photograph everyone, the hot-list justification is just policy — and policy changes.

If your town is being sold this same line, don't just take the vendor's word for it. Check whether cameras already ring your neighborhood on our map, and if you want to push back at a council meeting, our take-action page has what you need to start.

This is DeFlock The USA’s original commentary. The video above is the work of Verified Privacy VPN (vp.net), published on YouTube — full credit to the creator.