★ Independent, reader-supported & ad-free · Watching the watchers in all 50 states ★ Support Us
Watch · Our Take

Can police ask for your doorbell video? Here's what you should know

6abc Philadelphia · 3 years ago

The short version: 6abc's doorbell-camera explainer is a good consent refresher, but it skips the bigger issue: networks like Flock don't need your permission at all.

Our Take

6abc Philadelphia's segment on doorbell cameras covers useful ground — yes, you can say no when an officer asks for your Ring footage without a warrant, and that consent question actually matters. But the whole premise assumes a world where surveillance still requires you to say yes or no. That world is shrinking fast.

Flock Safety's ALPR cameras don't knock on your door. They're bolted to poles at the entrance to your neighborhood, logging every car that passes, tagging it with a timestamp and location, and feeding it into a searchable database that police departments across the country can query — often without a warrant, a subpoena, or even a specific suspect in mind. There's no consent conversation because you're not a person to that camera, you're a plate number. The doorbell debate is about your rights over your own footage; the Flock debate is about a private company building a movement log on everyone, whether you opted in or not.

If a local news station is willing to spend airtime explaining doorbell-camera consent, it's worth asking why the far more sweeping ALPR network gets so little scrutiny. Check our map to see if Flock cameras are already tracking your street, and hit up take action if you want to push back before it becomes the new normal.

This is DeFlock The USA’s original commentary. The video above is the work of 6abc Philadelphia, published on YouTube — full credit to the creator.