★ Independent, reader-supported & ad-free · Watching the watchers in all 50 states ★ Support Us
Watch · Our Take

Grass Valley police remove re-installed Flock cameras after contract ends

KCRA 3 · 4 weeks ago

The short version: Grass Valley PD had to pull Flock cameras reinstalled without a valid contract, a small but telling slip in oversight of local ALPR surveillance.

Our Take

Credit to KCRA 3 for catching this one: Grass Valley police reinstalling Flock Safety cameras after the city's contract had already lapsed isn't just a paperwork hiccup, it's a window into how little friction stands between "the agreement ended" and "the cameras are still watching you." If a department can flip the switch back on without anyone noticing until a reporter asks questions, that tells you how thin the accountability layer around these systems really is in most cities.

This is the pattern we see again and again with Flock deployments: minimal public notice when contracts are signed, even less when they expire or get renewed, and almost no real-time transparency about which cameras are live on any given day. Residents are left trusting that a private vendor and a local PD are keeping each other honest, with no independent check in between. A contract ending should mean the hardware goes dark — not that it takes a news crew to make that happen.

Grass Valley is a small city, but this is exactly the kind of quiet mistake that lets automated surveillance networks outlive the public's consent to have them. Check our camera map to see what's logged near you, and if your city has a Flock contract coming up for renewal, head to take-action to learn how to push for real oversight before the cameras go back up.

This is DeFlock The USA’s original commentary. The video above is the work of KCRA 3, published on YouTube — full credit to the creator.