★ Independent, reader-supported & ad-free · Watching the watchers in all 50 states ★ Support Us
Watch · Our Take

HOA says new license plate reading cameras will deter crime in the neighborhood

KING 5 Seattle · 2 years ago

The short version: A Seattle-area HOA is trading residents' privacy for the promise of ALPR-powered crime deterrence, with little proof the trade actually works.

Our Take

KING 5 Seattle's segment captures a scene playing out in HOAs across the country: a board votes to install license plate readers, tells residents it's for safety, and that's the end of the public debate. What doesn't usually get asked is who else can access that data once it's flowing into a private network, how long it's stored, and whether "deterrence" is anything more than a marketing line from the camera vendor.

Flock Safety and similar companies have built a business model on selling HOAs and small municipalities the idea that constant vehicle tracking equals crime prevention. The research on that claim is thin at best, but the privacy cost is concrete: every car entering the neighborhood gets logged, timestamped, and potentially shared with police departments or federal agencies through data-sharing agreements most residents never voted on and can't opt out of.

An HOA board isn't a police department, but the surveillance infrastructure it installs works exactly the same way, and often plugs into the same nationwide network. If you want to see how many of these cameras are already watching your own street, check our map, and if you're dealing with a similar push in your community, our take-action guide has steps for pushing back before the cameras go up.

This is DeFlock The USA’s original commentary. The video above is the work of KING 5 Seattle, published on YouTube — full credit to the creator.