★ Independent, reader-supported & ad-free · Watching the watchers in all 50 states ★ Support Us
Watch · Our Take

Man suspected of fatally shooting mother in Wyandotte

CBS Detroit · 4 weeks ago

The short version: CBS Detroit reports Michigan and Ohio ALPR networks tracked a missing car across state lines to a fatal police encounter, reviving the 'ALPRs solve crimes' narrative without addressing who else's movements got swept up.

Our Take

CBS Detroit's report on the Wyandotte homicide reads like the case study Flock Safety and its peers love to hand out: a car flagged, a trail picked up two states away, an arrest attempt within days. It's the story that gets cities to sign contracts without asking harder questions, because nobody wants to be the council member who voted against catching a killer.

But notice what's missing from this kind of coverage — any accounting of how many other plates got scanned, stored, and cross-referenced in two states to produce that one hit. Every driver on those highways in Michigan and Ohio had their location, timestamp, and vehicle logged into a database they never agreed to be part of, retained for who knows how long, accessible to agencies with no warrant requirement. That's the tradeoff these stories never mention: a single solved case used to justify a dragnet that watches everyone.

We're not in the business of pretending ALPRs never help close a case. We're in the business of asking who's watching the watchers, how long they keep the data, and whether your town's cameras are logged anywhere near the number of departments quietly sharing that information. Check our map to see what's already watching your neighborhood, and head to take action if you want your city to answer for it.

This is DeFlock The USA’s original commentary. The video above is the work of CBS Detroit, published on YouTube — full credit to the creator.