★ Independent, reader-supported & ad-free · Watching the watchers in all 50 states ★ Support Us
Watch · Our Take

R111 video

Lewis Shupe · 2 weeks ago

The short version: A resident-shot clip of Allentown's city council debating Resolution R111 shows how ALPR expansion decisions often happen in sparsely attended meetings with little public pushback.

Our Take

Credit to Lewis Shupe for doing the unglamorous work of pointing a camera at a council chamber and hitting record. R111, as discussed in this footage out of Allentown, is a reminder that the decisions expanding license plate reader networks rarely happen at press conferences — they happen in agenda item number eleven on a Tuesday night, in front of a half-empty room. That's exactly the setting where civil liberties get traded away quietly, one resolution at a time.

We don't have the full text of R111 in front of us, so we won't pretend to know every provision. But the pattern is familiar: a vendor contract or policy update gets framed as a routine public-safety upgrade, council members ask a handful of surface-level questions, and the vote goes through with minimal scrutiny of data retention, sharing agreements, or audit requirements. Those are the details that determine whether a camera system stays a narrow investigative tool or becomes a standing record of everyone's movements.

If you're in Allentown or anywhere with a council considering Flock cameras, the time to ask hard questions is before the vote, not after. Check our camera map to see what's already been deployed near you, and use our take-action resources to show up prepared the next time an item like R111 lands on an agenda.

This is DeFlock The USA’s original commentary. The video above is the work of Lewis Shupe, published on YouTube — full credit to the creator.