★ Independent, reader-supported & ad-free · Watching the watchers in all 50 states ★ Support Us
Watch · Our Take

Privacy concerns over NYPD and Ring partnership

FOX 5 New York · 4 years ago

The short version: FOX 5 New York flags privacy worries over NYPD's Ring partnership, a reminder that doorbell cameras plus police requests can quietly become a citywide surveillance net.

Our Take

FOX 5 New York's segment on the NYPD's relationship with Ring taps into something we've been watching closely: the slow merger of private doorbell cameras and public policing. Individually, a Ring camera is just a homeowner's choice. But when police departments build formal pipelines to request footage from thousands of these devices, you get something closer to a distributed surveillance network than a neighborhood watch — one built without warrants, public votes, or much oversight.

What makes these partnerships tricky is the illusion of consent. Homeowners think they're protecting their porch packages, not feeding a searchable archive that police can tap into repeatedly, across neighborhoods, over time. Combine that with license plate readers like Flock Safety's, and you get a much fuller picture of who's coming and going than most residents realize exists. The FOX 5 report is a useful nudge to ask: who approved this, what are the retention rules, and who's watching the watchers?

This is exactly the kind of quiet infrastructure expansion we track. Check our camera map to see what's already deployed near you, and hit take action if you want to push back on unchecked camera partnerships in your own city.

This is DeFlock The USA’s original commentary. The video above is the work of FOX 5 New York, published on YouTube — full credit to the creator.