★ Independent, reader-supported & ad-free · Watching the watchers in all 50 states ★ Support Us
Watch · Our Take

San Jose police officer fired for misusing Flock camera data, chief says

NBC Bay Area · 3 days ago

The short version: A San Jose officer's firing for misusing Flock ALPR data shows the 'trust us' promise behind license plate surveillance keeps failing in practice.

Our Take

Credit to NBC Bay Area for reporting this one out. A San Jose police officer got fired after allegedly digging through the department's Flock Safety camera network for reasons that had nothing to do with an actual investigation. That's not a hypothetical civil-liberties concern anymore — it's a personnel file.

Every time Flock and its police partners pitch these camera networks to a city council, the sales pitch leans hard on "audit logs" and "policy safeguards." Fine, the logs apparently worked this time and someone got caught. But catching misuse after the fact doesn't undo the fact that a government employee had casual access to a rolling record of where people drive, park, and go — and used it for something outside the rules. Audit trails are a cleanup tool, not a lock on the door. The db of scanned plates already exists the moment the cameras go up, and every login is a chance for someone to poke around for personal reasons: an ex, a neighbor, a rival, a story that never makes the news.

This is exactly the kind of incident we track because it's rarely isolated to one department. If your city has these cameras, or you're not sure, check our map to see what's already watching your streets, and head to our take-action page for ways to push your local council on real oversight before the next "misuse" story breaks.

This is DeFlock The USA’s original commentary. The video above is the work of NBC Bay Area, published on YouTube — full credit to the creator.