★ Independent, reader-supported & ad-free · Watching the watchers in all 50 states ★ Support Us
Watch · Our Take

We were Flocked hard!

Daytona Beach Lawyer · 1 month ago

The short version: A retired homicide detective turned defense lawyer dissects how Flock ALPR data helped put an innocent woman in jail for 13 days over a crash she didn't cause.

Our Take

Daytona Beach Lawyer — a retired homicide detective who now practices criminal defense — brings a perspective most commentary on Flock Safety lacks: someone who has run investigations from inside a police department and now picks them apart in court. His breakdown of the Lindsey Isaacs case, which has since made it onto NewsNation, cuts to the real failure point. It's not just that a license-plate-reader hit was wrong. It's that investigators apparently treated a Flock match as corroboration strong enough to justify an arrest, rather than as one unverified data point that still needed old-fashioned police work to confirm or rule out.

That distinction matters because it's the whole argument against building prosecutions around ALPR networks in the first place. These cameras log plates, not people, and they do it with error rates, misreads, and database lag that most departments never explain to the public — or apparently, in this case, scrutinize closely enough before making an arrest. When a system marketed as near-infallible gets treated that way by the officers using it, the person sitting in a cell for two weeks pays for that misplaced confidence. Isaacs isn't an edge case to wave away; she's a preview of what happens when probable cause gets outsourced to a camera network with no court oversight and no transparency requirement in most states.

We appreciate Daytona Beach Lawyer putting a trained investigator's eye on this instead of just repeating the headline. If you want to know how exposed your own community is, check our camera map to see where Flock has installed readers near you, and visit our take-action page for ways to push back before your town's police department makes the same mistake.

This is DeFlock The USA’s original commentary. The video above is the work of Daytona Beach Lawyer, published on YouTube — full credit to the creator.