★ Independent, reader-supported & ad-free · Watching the watchers in all 50 states ★ Support Us
Watch · Our Take

Law professor: Amazon turning over Ring footage is troubling | NewsNation Tonight

NewsNation · 4 years ago

The short version: A law professor's warning about Amazon handing Ring footage to police underscores how private camera networks quietly feed the same surveillance dragnet as Flock's ALPRs.

Our Take

NewsNation's sit-down with law professor Lawrence Cappello puts a finger on something we've been screaming about from the ALPR side of the fence: it doesn't matter whether the camera is bolted to a doorbell or a traffic pole, the endgame is the same. Ring footage flowing to police without a warrant, often without the homeowner even knowing, is the same permissionless data pipeline that Flock Safety has built for license plates. Different hardware, same appetite.

What makes this worth your attention is the pattern, not the product. Private company builds convenient surveillance tool, private company partners quietly with law enforcement, private company decides your data isn't really yours once a cop asks nicely. Cappello's unease is well placed. We've watched Flock's ALPR network expand into thousands of towns under this exact playbook, and the "it's just for solving crimes" pitch never comes with a warrant requirement attached.

Credit to NewsNation and Cappello for putting this on mainstream TV, because most people still think of Ring and Flock as separate issues. They're not. They're the same fight over whether private surveillance infrastructure gets to operate as a shadow arm of the state with none of the accountability. If you want to see how far the camera network has spread near you, check our map, and if you're ready to push back locally, our take-action page has next steps.

This is DeFlock The USA’s original commentary. The video above is the work of NewsNation, published on YouTube — full credit to the creator.